Label facts comparison

ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe vs Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food

ACANA and Hill's Science Diet, compared on source-backed label facts. Scores are not used on comparison pages — neither product is placed above the other; the facts sit side by side so the trade-offs are readable.

ACANA

ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe

Dog · Dry · All Life Stages

Product details

Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food

Dog · Dry · Adult

Product details

Listed label values

Scaled to the larger listed value per axis. Larger means a larger listed amount — not better. Missing values stay at zero and are reported as not listed.

ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe
Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food

Per-axis percentages for the compared items.
Axis	ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Protein	25%	24%
Fat	15%	8%
Fiber	6%	5%
Carbs	Not listed	Not listed
Calories	397 kcal/cup	298 kcal/cup
Moisture	12% max	10% max

Quick scan

Core label facts

A short summary before the complete recorded label tables.

Label fact	ACANA ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science Diet Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Protein (min)	25%	24%
Fat (min)	15%	8%
Fiber (max)	6%	5%
Moisture (max)	12%	10%
Calories	3305 kcal/kg	3189 kcal/kg
First ingredients	Salmon, herring meal, pearled barley, whole peas, oat groats	Chicken, cracked pearled barley, brown rice, pea fiber, corn gluten meal

Product identity

Product and label details

Recorded identity, audience, format, package, and adequacy information.

Label field	ACANAACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Full label title	ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe Dry Dog Food	Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Species	Dog	Dog
Life stage	All Life Stages	Adult
Food format	Dry	Dry
Product line	ACANA Classics	Science Diet Perfect Weight
Flavor / recipe	Salmon & Barley	Chicken & Brown Rice
Processing stated	Not listed	Extruded kibble
Nutritional adequacy statement	ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for all life stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lb or more as an adult).	This food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for maintenance of adult dogs.
Adequacy method	AAFCO profile statement	AAFCO profile statement
Complete and balanced recorded	Yes	Yes

Recorded nutrients

Guaranteed analysis and calories

Minimums and maximums are reproduced as recorded. A larger number is not automatically better.

Label field	ACANAACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Crude protein (min)	25%	24%
Crude fat (min)	15%	8%
Crude fiber (max)	6%	5%
Moisture (max)	12%	10%
Calcium	1.2%	Not listed
Phosphorus	1%	Not listed
Omega-3	0.8%	Not listed
Omega-6	2.1%	Not listed
Taurine	0.1%	Not listed
Glucosamine	300 mg/kg	Not listed
Calories	3305 kcal/kg	3189 kcal/kg
Calories per cup	397 kcal/cup	298 kcal/cup

Formula context

Ingredients and formulation comparison

Ingredient order and recorded formulation flags provide context; they do not establish whole-product quality on their own.

Label field	ACANAACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
First five ingredients	Salmon, herring meal, pearled barley, whole peas, oat groats	Chicken, cracked pearled barley, brown rice, pea fiber, corn gluten meal
Full ingredient list	View full recorded list (44) Salmon (unresolved mapping), herring meal (unresolved mapping), pearled barley (unresolved mapping), whole peas (unresolved mapping), oat groats (unresolved mapping), pork fat (unresolved mapping), whole oats (unresolved mapping), lentil fiber (unresolved mapping), natural fish flavor (unresolved mapping), pea starch (unresolved mapping), fish oil (unresolved mapping), dicalcium phosphate (unresolved mapping), calcium carbonate (unresolved mapping), potassium chloride (unresolved mapping), dried kelp (unresolved mapping), choline chloride (unresolved mapping), vitamin E supplement (unresolved mapping), salt (unresolved mapping), zinc proteinate (unresolved mapping), vitamin C (ascorbic acid) (unresolved mapping), mixed tocopherols (preservative) (unresolved mapping), taurine (unresolved mapping), vitamin A supplement (unresolved mapping), vitamin D3 supplement (unresolved mapping), iron proteinate (unresolved mapping), whole apples (unresolved mapping), whole butternut squash (unresolved mapping), whole carrots (unresolved mapping), collard greens (unresolved mapping), whole pears (unresolved mapping), whole pumpkin (unresolved mapping), niacin (unresolved mapping), thiamine mononitrate (unresolved mapping), calcium pantothenate (unresolved mapping), pyridoxine hydrochloride (unresolved mapping), riboflavin (unresolved mapping), folic acid (unresolved mapping), vitamin B12 supplement (unresolved mapping), copper proteinate (unresolved mapping), citric acid (preservative) (unresolved mapping), rosemary extract (unresolved mapping), dried Lactobacillus acidophilus fermentation product (unresolved mapping), dried Bifidobacterium animalis fermentation product (unresolved mapping), dried Lactobacillus casei fermentation product (unresolved mapping).	View full recorded list (15) Chicken (unresolved mapping), cracked pearled barley (unresolved mapping), brown rice (unresolved mapping), pea fiber (unresolved mapping), corn gluten meal (unresolved mapping), chicken meal (unresolved mapping), dried tomato pomace (unresolved mapping), oat fiber (unresolved mapping), chicken liver flavor (unresolved mapping), flaxseed (unresolved mapping), dried beet pulp (unresolved mapping), coconut oil (unresolved mapping), lactic acid (unresolved mapping), vitamins (unresolved mapping), and minerals (unresolved mapping).
Primary protein source	Salmon	Chicken
Primary carbohydrate source	Pearled barley, oat groats, and whole oats	Barley and brown rice
Grain-free label	Not listed	No
Probiotics recorded	Yes — Lactobacillus acidophilus; Bifidobacterium animalis; Lactobacillus casei	Not listed
Animal protein listed first	Yes	Yes
Plant protein concentrate recorded	Not listed	Yes
Legume recorded	Yes	Yes
Generic animal ingredient flag	Yes	Not listed
Filler-presence flag	Not listed	Yes

Label-based calculations

Calculated nutrition context

These values are recorded or calculated from label data. They do not evaluate the product, and missing inputs stay Not listed.

Label field	ACANAACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Protein per 1,000 kcal	75.6 g	75.3 g
Fat per 1,000 kcal	45.4 g	25.1 g

Provenance

Source and review record

Use the official links to check current packaging and formulation details. A source confidence note is CMS record metadata; it does not evaluate the product or replace Data Confidence.

Label field	ACANAACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe	Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food
Official source	Open official source (opens in a new tab)	Open official source (opens in a new tab)
Source site	ACANA	Hill's
Source confidence note	High	High
Source checked date	Not listed	Not listed

Differences worth noting

ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe lists a higher protein minimum (25% vs 24%). Whether that fits depends on the pet, not the number alone.
ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe is more calorie-dense (3305 vs 3189 kcal/kg) — feeding amounts differ accordingly.

Adjust this comparison ACANA Classics Salmon & Barley Recipe details Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dog Food details

Similar comparisons

Label facts come from official sources and can change with reformulations. This page compares recorded facts only — it does not evaluate fit for an individual pet. For diet questions tied to a health condition, ask your veterinarian.